$20.00
1
Your cart is empty
Subtotal
We will hold your cart for 15:00.
Buy more, save more
Coupon discount
Shipping
Add 2 more items to unlock your free mystery gift.
Complimentary item.
Total
$20.00
We will hold your cart for 15:00.
So you’re finally upgrading your mismatched Tupperware collection. Good. But before you hit “add to cart,” take a breath. The perfect food storage set doesn’t exist — but the right set for your kitchen does. This pre-purchase checklist will save you from buying something you’ll end up hating six months from now. We’ll walk you through everything from glass vs. plastic to lid seals, stackability, and even how your containers fit in your fridge. By the end, you’ll know exactly what to look for — and which Pyrex and Joseph Joseph sets pass the test.
Before you start comparing sets, open your fridge and your pantry. What do you store most? Soups, stews, and liquids need leakproof, airtight containers. Dry goods like pasta and cereal can go in anything that seals. If you meal prep with multiple portions of the same meal, you’ll want identical containers that stack neatly. If you pack lunches, you might want smaller, individual containers. Take note of the sizes you reach for most — that’s what your new set should prioritize.
This is the big one. Glass containers are non-porous, so they won’t absorb tomato sauce stains or garlic smells. They also go from fridge to oven (check the temp rating on the base) and are microwave-safe without worrying about BPA or phthalates. The downsides? They’re heavier, and you have to be careful with thermal shock — don’t take a cold dish and throw it straight into a hot oven. Plastic, on the other hand, is lighter, cheaper, and often has clip-on lids that are easier to seal. But plastic can warp in the dishwasher and absorbs odors over time.
If you store leftovers for the whole week and like to reheat directly in the container, all-glass is the way to go. If you’re packing lunches or your kids are carrying them to school, a mix of both is fine. Pyrex Ultimate 10-piece set is a solid investment if you want glass lids that are also oven-safe (up to a point). For a budget-friendly glass pick, the Pyrex Simply Store Tinted 2-cup rounds are a dependable choice.
For those who want a little color and a lighter footprint, Joseph Joseph’s Nest Lock set uses robust food-safe plastic with an airtight silicone seal — perfect for fridge, not for oven.
A storage container is only as good as its lid. You want an airtight seal to keep food fresh longer and prevent spills in your bag. Look for lids with a silicone gasket or a clip mechanism. Some lids are easier to close than others — try them in store if you can, or read reviews. Joseph Joseph’s Nest Lock range has a patented locking system that creates an airtight seal with just one click. The clear, stackable bodies make it easy to see what’s inside.
If you’re going with Pyrex, the classic plastic lids are not airtight unless the container has a “FreshLock” or “Snapware” system. But for everyday leftovers, they do a decent job. Just be aware that liquid may leak in a lunch bag. If that’s a concern, opt for clip-lock lids or glass lids with a gasket.
No one wants a cracked container. Check the temperature range for everything you buy. Pyrex glass is freezer-safe and microwave-safe, and you can put it in a preheated oven up to 425°F (check the specific dish). But the plastic lids are almost never oven-safe. The Pyrex Ultimate set with glass lids is a game-changer because the lids themselves are oven-safe (again, check the temp). Joseph Joseph Nest Lock containers are not oven-safe; they're for fridge and microwave use only. Always read the base of the container for exact limits.
Containers that nest and stack are the difference between a tidy cabinet and a chaotic pile. Look for sets where the same size containers stack flush, and where different sizes nest inside one another when empty. Joseph Joseph’s Nest line was literally built for this — the containers and lids nest together to save vertical space. Pyrex round containers also stack well, but the lids can be bulky. If you're short on cabinet space, nesting is non-negotiable.
Most commercial food storage is dishwasher safe, but plastic lids tend to warp on the bottom rack. Put lids on the top rack or hand wash them. Glass bases are fine on the bottom. If you buy a set with glass lids, those are also dishwasher safe. Just be consistent: high heat can degrade silicone gaskets over time, so most manufacturers recommend top rack for anything with a rubber seal. Follow the care instructions — it'll extend the life of your purchase.
It goes without saying, but make sure any plastic you buy is BPA-free and food-grade. Pyrex is famously non-toxic; their glass is tempered and free of harmful chemicals. Joseph Joseph uses food-safe ABS plastic and silicone. Hefty's trash bags aren't for food storage, so ignore those for this checklist. If you're concerned about chemicals, glass is the safest bet.
Lids get lost, warped, or cracked. Before you commit to a set, check if replacement lids are available for purchase. Pyrex sells replacement lids for most of their Simply Store and Ultimate lines. We stock a selection of Pyrex replacement lids and containers, so you can mix and match. It’s also why we recommend buying sets with common lid sizes. For example, you can pair a Pyrex Simply Store 3-cup rectangular container with a 7-cup round tinted container — different shapes, but the lids are sized for each.
Measure your fridge drawers and cabinet shelves. A 7-cup round container might look great online, but if it doesn't fit in your designated spot, it's a frustration. The Joseph Joseph FridgeStore under-shelf drawer is a clever way to add vertical storage inside the fridge without taking up shelf space. It slides under a shelf and holds small containers or produce. That kind of organizer can help you use every inch of your fridge, especially if you have a lot of round containers.
A 10-piece set for $70 might seem pricey, but if you use those containers three times a week for a year, that's less than 4 cents per use. Cheap sets that warp or crack after a few months are no bargain. Also consider the cost of replacement lids: if a lid costs $5 and you lose two a year, a cheap set can get expensive. Look at the material quality, warranty, and whether the brand stands behind its products.
If you're ready to start shopping, browse our food storage collection. We carry Pyrex glass sets, Joseph Joseph space-saving containers, and even the FridgeStore drawer to keep everything tidy. And if you have a favorite brand or a storage hack, share it in the comments—we'd love to hear from you.